MEET THE OWNERS
Clay Kaltenbach
Clay Kaltenbach is a dynamic entrepreneur and real estate professional based in Central Ohio. He is one of the owners of Plain City Barbell, a community-focused strength and fitness facility dedicated to training, wellness, and building a strong local culture around health and performance. In addition to his work in fitness, Clay is a licensed real estate agent serving the Central Ohio market, where he helps clients navigate residential and investment opportunities with a practical, relationship-driven approach. He is also an active auctioneer, bringing energy, professionalism, and precision to both live and online auction events across the region. ​A lifelong resident of Plain City and graduate of Jonathan Alder, Clay remains deeply connected to the community that shaped him. Alongside his professional roles, he continues to invest in opportunities that support long-term growth and contribute to the local economy. Through fitness, real estate, and auctioneering, Clay is focused on building strong relationships and creating lasting impact throughout Central Ohio.
Jay Kaltenbach
Jay Kaltenbach is a Central Ohio real estate professional, private investor, and farmer with deep roots in the Plain City community. Raised in Plain City, Ohio, Jay built his foundation through hard work, agriculture, and a strong connection to local values that continue to guide his personal and professional life. He is currently based in Powell, Ohio, where he lives with his wife, Shirley. Together they have two children, Clay and Cora. Professionally, Jay works as a licensed real estate agent and is actively involved in private real estate investment, including long-term holds and Airbnb properties. His background in farming has shaped a practical, hands-on approach to land, property, and investment strategy. With experience spanning agriculture, residential real estate, and short-term rental investments, Jay focuses on building long-term value while staying closely tied to the Central Ohio communities he knows well.
Jerry Kaltenbach
As a graduate of Jonathan Alder High School, I was born and raised in Plain City and have lived in the community my entire life. Being a professional Firefighter/Paramedic for the past 28 years has brought forth my passion to help people. I enjoy working with student athletes and have spent the past 3 years working closely with the High School baseball team during their offseason workouts. Weight training has been a part of my lifestyle since high school and has played a huge role in staying relatively injury free in my profession. I have been married for 29 years to my wife, Lisa, and we have 3 children, Trent, Hunter and Alexa.